Logo
  • Performers
  • Search
  • Curations

Insights. Oversupply. Can music make you sick?

  • Play all
  • Download
  • Share

Description
Can Music Make You Sick? Measuring the price of musical ambition (book extract) October 8, 2020 Tags: wellbeing ‘Can Music Make You Sick?‘ is a new book by Sally Anne Gross and Dr George Musgrave, with its roots in a study of the same name commissioned by charity Help Musicians UK in 2017, about mental health in the music industry. Ahead of World Mental Health Day on 10 October, Gross and Musgrave have shared an excerpt from the book with Music Ally, and have also introduced it. “This extract below is taken from Chapter 4 of our book entitled ‘The Status of Value’. In this chapter we examine the ways in which musicians seek answers to questions concerning what musical work ‘is’, what it means, and what ‘success’ is, and the impact this can have their emotional wellbeing. As we suggest: “This findings of this chapter are threefold. Firstly, as artists live out their musical lives increasingly in the public glare online, they report their sense of wellbeing being undermined. The vulnerability of being ‘on display’ they perceive as harmful as this is also coming within a feedback loop of appraisal and valuation. There is a link between extreme levels of competition in the marketplace and the need artists feel to maintain relevance within their musical genre and for the wider music industries. In this atmosphere of abundance, it becomes increasingly difficult to achieve the central aim of musical production – meaningful connection. Secondly, when artists engage with the music industry, high levels of anxiety might be explained by seeking contracts as a marker of status within an environment which musicians feel is often defined by luck. Luck, we suggest, is a myth that serves to [blur] the reality of pre-existing power and network relations in the music industries; putting things down to ‘bad luck’ is, in a high-risk industry, an almost perfect excuse, letting everybody concerned off the hook. In this environment, musicians hope that their work produces the required stickiness to ensure that they not only get heard but that they can make authentic connections that allow their careers to grow. Thirdly, there is a complex and contradictory relationship between the idea of being in control and the impact this has on inevitable failures which were reported to be internalised despite not always being internally attributed. These three features of ‘the status of value’ demonstrate how artists in the contemporary music industries come to suffer when they begin the process of situating their work within the cultural field of production and the complex processes of [acquiring ‘success’] necessary when one wants to be heard”. The extract we have chosen below comes from the early part of the chapter in which we explore the relationship between high levels of competition – competition for the attention of listeners, for status, for career progression, for support from organisations and institutions, etc – and the need to stay ‘relevant’. One of the central themes of our book is that of abundance, and what an environment of musical abundance feels like for those making music, and getting heard and staying heard is key. We start by hearing from one of the musicians we interviewed.” The book extract follows. can music make you sick Measuring the Price of Musical Ambition “If you’ve got an app on your phone that can access all the new music, every single artist in the whole world at the touch of a button, you don’t actually need to commit, not even 79p to hear or own that song. I think that… furthers that feeling that these tracks, these pieces of music that people are creating, they essentially are disposable… I do listen to ‘New Music Friday’ in my car and things like that, so you’re starting to feel like it’s harder than ever for a musician. You can’t afford to stop creating. You can’t afford to take too long on what you’re doing or get too attached to it because it’s faster moving than ever before. And that just furthers that kind of sense of anxiety. —Producer/Songwriter, M, Pop, London This extract contains so much richness. It speaks to how the massive oversupply of music sits within an equally unimaginable stream of news and media information in the last decade, as Dean (2009) amongst others have pointed out. This has created an unquantifiable and unimaginable music market that begins to feel less like abundance or ‘ubiquity’ and more like what Steyerl (2011) calls an invasion and occupation. In this setting it is not music that is scarce but rather time and attention across the whole media landscape from consumers, prosumers, retailers, gatekeepers, etc. For the musicians we spoke to, the online, digital world moves at astonishing speed: too fast to make sense of. It is disorientating and anxiety-inducing whereby some of the musicians we spoke to were forced to adopt an ‘on to the next one’ approach i.e. this song is made and finished, it’s time to make another one. Indeed, Billboard recently suggested that this rapid-fire approach to music making was ‘the new normal’ (Enis, 2020), whereby ‘simply keeping an artist’s name in people’s minds can be incredibly difficult’ and constantly releasing music becomes ‘a way to maintain a presence in the conversation.’ The sheer volume and abundance of music – or even simply its perceived volume and abundance (Musgrave, 2017) – is exhausting and overwhelming. It is in this environment that the concept of relevancy, and the idea of maintaining relevancy online where attention is the key currency, becomes so central to understanding the working lives of musicians today. As the producer above puts it: “You can’t afford to stop creating”. Another interviewee told us: ‘When you see how difficult it is and how many other people are doing it… I think it’s this whole big vicious cycle of, as your self-worth decreases, you become more anxious’ (Musician, F, Indie/ Musical theatre, Belfast). Immediately following the tragic suicide of EDM superstar Avicii in 2018, many questions were asked about his exhausting touring schedule and the impact this had on his physical and mental wellbeing. Of course, there were a wide range of reasons for this schedule, one of which being financial, but looking at his timetable of not only performances, but also radio interviews, television appearances, photo opportunities and ‘meet and greets’ along with everything that goes along with touring, we saw the most extreme and debilitating version of what our interviewees described: the need to stay relevant in an environment of competitive abundance. It is one thing to try and work out if you are successful, but more than this, if you don’t keep releasing music, how do you know you exist? You need to play this gig because if you don’t, someone else will. You need to appear on this radio show because if you don’t, someone else will. You need to get your song played and released and heard, because if you don’t, someone else will. This quest to maintain relevancy within your musical network and the perpetual engagement facilitated by technology is one of the factors which the musicians we spoke to identified as contributing towards an exhausting workload which feels both constant and apparently endless… There is an implicit, positive idea that the sheer amount of music being made is socially beneficial as it represents diversity, and a widening of communication and mass creative expression; evidence of participatory democracy in action. However, participatory culture and the abundance of music – as well as all kinds of other media – cannot simply be described in positive terms. For those working in and aspiring to work in the music sector, the amount of music is, our interviewees told us, part of the difficulty. When struggling to stay seen and stay heard, and in finding metrics to affirm and communicate different modalities of status, the questions which matter come to be: How many views does your song have? How many retweets did your tweet get? Nice track, when is the next one coming out? What’s next? Today, sending messages and creating content appears to be all that matters, or is certainly a large part of it. This is what our interviewee earlier characterised as the fact that he ‘can’t afford to take too long on what you’re doing or get too attached to it’ (Producer/Songwriter, M, Pop, London). However, this can be painful for musicians who so embody their labour, and who are often, personally, seeking very different things from their work. Can Music Make You Sick? is available to buy now. The ebook version is also open access from the publisher. https://www.uwestminsterpress.co.uk/site/books/m/10.16997/book43/
Expand all  
Packshot
Play
Title
Version
Waveform
Code
Composer
Album
Duration
Description
Tags
  • The Catalyst

    The Catalyst

    CWLMP000020 Joel Lundberg: Music From a Room

      The Catalyst

      Recording identifier: Label: Klang-Skivan Catalogue number: Conductors: Producer: Joel Lundberg Engineer: Johannes Lundberg Recording date: 2018-12-22 Performance timing: Ensemble: Leader: Kalle Stenbäcken Recording location: Studio Epidemin, Gothenburg, Sweden

      CWLMP000020

      The Catalyst

      CWLMP000020

        Joel Lundberg: Music From a Room

        04:10

        Recording identifier: Label: Klang-Skivan Catalogue number: Conductors: Producer: Joel Lundberg Engineer: Johannes Lundberg Recording date: 2018-12-22 Performance timing: Ensemble: Leader: Kalle Stenbäcken Recording location: Studio Epidemin, Gothenburg, Sweden

        04:10

        • Add to cart
        • Add to project
        • Download
        • Stems
        • Cue sheet info
        • Similar
        • Share
        • Note
        • Like
        • Show actions
        • Details
      • Sarcasms, Op. 17

        Tempestoso

        cwlTemp015 Veronika Jaklová: Eastern European miniatures

          Tempestoso

          Standing rather apart from the salon pieces, Impressionist evocations and fairy tales that make up the bulk of early twentieth-century piano miniatures, there are also some that have their sights set more on innovation and experiment. Prokofiev’s own Sarcasms, composed between 1912 and 1914 are certainly among his most experimental works before his period of self-imposed exile from 1918. No doubt there was an element of image-consciousness here, too, right from the beginning. Prokofiev revelled in the controversy provoked by his more extravagant compositions and performances. In 1941 he reflected on the fifth Sarcasm, perhaps again with a degree of hindsight: ‘Sometimes we laugh maliciously at someone or something, but when we look closer, we see how pathetic and unfortunate is the object of our laughter. Then we become uncomfortable and the laughter rings in our ears, laughing now at us.’ But there is no need to take these compositions too seriously. Equally plausible is the response of the noted Russian virtuoso Konstantin Igumnov to the same piece: ‘This is the image of a reveller. He has been up to mischief, has broken plates and dishes, and has been kicked downstairs; he lies there and finally begins to come to his senses; but he is still unable to tell his right foot from his left.’

          cwlTemp015

          Tempestoso

          cwlTemp015

            Veronika Jaklová: Eastern European miniatures

            02:10

            Standing rather apart from the salon pieces, Impressionist evocations and fairy tales that make up the bulk of early twentieth-century piano miniatures, there are also some that have their sights set more on innovation and experiment. Prokofiev’s own Sarcasms, composed between 1912 and 1914 are certainly among his most experimental works before his period of self-imposed exile from 1918. No doubt there was an element of image-consciousness here, too, right from the beginning. Prokofiev revelled in the controversy provoked by his more extravagant compositions and performances. In 1941 he reflected on the fifth Sarcasm, perhaps again with a degree of hindsight: ‘Sometimes we laugh maliciously at someone or something, but when we look closer, we see how pathetic and unfortunate is the object of our laughter. Then we become uncomfortable and the laughter rings in our ears, laughing now at us.’ But there is no need to take these compositions too seriously. Equally plausible is the response of the noted Russian virtuoso Konstantin Igumnov to the same piece: ‘This is the image of a reveller. He has been up to mischief, has broken plates and dishes, and has been kicked downstairs; he lies there and finally begins to come to his senses; but he is still unable to tell his right foot from his left.’

            4

            02:10

            • Add to cart
            • Add to project
            • Download
            • Stems
            • Cue sheet info
            • Similar
            • Share
            • Note
            • Like
            • Show actions
            • Details
          • Deux mouvements thématiques 'guitareies' pour piano

            Movement 1

            cwlTemp013 Alberto Portugheis: Elena Romero, Integrale pour piano

              Movement 1

              Recording identifier: Label: Catalogue number: Conductors: Producer: Engineer: Recording date: 2010-02-01 Performance timing: Ensemble: Leader: Recording location:

              cwlTemp013

              Movement 1

              cwlTemp013

                Alberto Portugheis: Elena Romero, Integrale pour piano

                02:58

                Recording identifier: Label: Catalogue number: Conductors: Producer: Engineer: Recording date: 2010-02-01 Performance timing: Ensemble: Leader: Recording location:

                1

                02:58

                • Add to cart
                • Add to project
                • Download
                • Stems
                • Cue sheet info
                • Similar
                • Share
                • Note
                • Like
                • Show actions
                • Details
              • Three concert etudes: 2. La leggierezza

                Etude No.2 La Leggierezza

                cwlTemp015 Veronika Jaklová: Eastern European miniatures

                  Etude No.2 La Leggierezza

                  Recording identifier: Label: Catalogue number: Conductors: Producer: Engineer: Ing. Milan Kormout-Wisocký, studio: JRS -Jethro Recording Studio Recording date: 2020-05-15 Performance timing: Ensemble: Leader: Recording location: Hall of Prague Conservatory

                  cwlTemp015

                  Etude No.2 La Leggierezza

                  cwlTemp015

                    Veronika Jaklová: Eastern European miniatures

                    05:42

                    Recording identifier: Label: Catalogue number: Conductors: Producer: Engineer: Ing. Milan Kormout-Wisocký, studio: JRS -Jethro Recording Studio Recording date: 2020-05-15 Performance timing: Ensemble: Leader: Recording location: Hall of Prague Conservatory

                    05:42

                    • Add to cart
                    • Add to project
                    • Download
                    • Stems
                    • Cue sheet info
                    • Similar
                    • Share
                    • Note
                    • Like
                    • Show actions
                    • Details
                  • Canto de Embalar

                    Canto de Embalar

                    cwlTemp014 Carlos Paredes for Solo Violin

                      Canto de Embalar

                      Recording identifier: Label: Catalogue number: Conductors: Producer: Engineer: Recording date: 2020-03-20 Performance timing: Ensemble: Leader: Recording location: Lisboa, Portugal

                      cwlTemp014

                      Canto de Embalar

                      cwlTemp014

                        Carlos Paredes for Solo Violin

                        03:23

                        Recording identifier: Label: Catalogue number: Conductors: Producer: Engineer: Recording date: 2020-03-20 Performance timing: Ensemble: Leader: Recording location: Lisboa, Portugal

                        03:23

                        • Add to cart
                        • Add to project
                        • Download
                        • Stems
                        • Cue sheet info
                        • Similar
                        • Share
                        • Note
                        • Like
                        • Show actions
                        • Details
                      • Khamooshaneh

                        Sourena Sefati-Khamooshaneh

                        cwlTemp011 Arghavan, by Sourena Sefati and Mojgan Shajarian

                          Sourena Sefati-Khamooshaneh

                          Composer: Sourena Sefati Singer: Mojgan Shajarian Khamooshaneh is a Persian word for “Mutely”. The song is composed on a poem of Shafiee Kadkani, one of the most famous contemporary poets in Iran. The poem is about the history of Iran, the country that has been repeatedly occupied by its enemies. Instruments used in the song are including: Tar, Bam Tar, Santour, Kamancheh, Tombak, and Frame Drums. The song was composed in Esfahan scale (Bayate Esfahan).

                          cwlTemp011

                          Sourena Sefati-Khamooshaneh

                          cwlTemp011

                            Arghavan, by Sourena Sefati and Mojgan Shajarian

                            07:23

                            Composer: Sourena Sefati Singer: Mojgan Shajarian Khamooshaneh is a Persian word for “Mutely”. The song is composed on a poem of Shafiee Kadkani, one of the most famous contemporary poets in Iran. The poem is about the history of Iran, the country that has been repeatedly occupied by its enemies. Instruments used in the song are including: Tar, Bam Tar, Santour, Kamancheh, Tombak, and Frame Drums. The song was composed in Esfahan scale (Bayate Esfahan).

                            07:23

                            • Add to cart
                            • Add to project
                            • Download
                            • Stems
                            • Cue sheet info
                            • Similar
                            • Share
                            • Note
                            • Like
                            • Show actions
                            • Details
                          • Setar Solo

                            Setar-Solo

                            cwlTemp011 Arghavan, by Sourena Sefati and Mojgan Shajarian

                              Setar-Solo

                              The piece is Kourosh Danaei’s improvisation in Esfahan scale (Bayate Esfahan). Setar is a Persian stringed instrument with four strings which is played with index right finger.

                              cwlTemp011

                              Setar-Solo

                              cwlTemp011

                                Arghavan, by Sourena Sefati and Mojgan Shajarian

                                01:23

                                The piece is Kourosh Danaei’s improvisation in Esfahan scale (Bayate Esfahan). Setar is a Persian stringed instrument with four strings which is played with index right finger.

                                01:23

                                • Add to cart
                                • Add to project
                                • Download
                                • Stems
                                • Cue sheet info
                                • Similar
                                • Share
                                • Note
                                • Like
                                • Show actions
                                • Details
                              • Piano Concerto in D flat Major

                                Allegro ma non troppo e maestoso

                                cwlTemp012 Alberto Portugheis: Khachaturian: Piano Concerto; Sonatina; Toccata

                                  Allegro ma non troppo e maestoso

                                  The Piano Concerto in D-flat was written for Lev Oborin, who premiered it in Moscow on 12 July 1937, with the Moscow Philharmonic Orchestra under Lev Steinberg. The only piano available for the premiere was an upright piano, and the orchestra had just one rehearsal. The venue was an open-air stage in Sokolniki Park, and during the performance a strong wind blew Steinberg's glasses off, so that he could no longer see the score and had to conduct the remainder from memory. The piece is in three movements: the first movement, Allegro ma non troppo e maestoso, makes extensive use of the three-note theme of F, B, and A♭, illustrated above. Although the term "flexatone" is used, the second movement, Andante con anima, is one of the few classical pieces to make use of a musical saw, although this instrument is often omitted in performances and recordings of the concerto. The third movement, Allegro brillante, caps the piece in an exciting manner.

                                  cwlTemp012

                                  Allegro ma non troppo e maestoso

                                  cwlTemp012

                                    Alberto Portugheis: Khachaturian: Piano Concerto; Sonatina; Toccata

                                    15:04

                                    The Piano Concerto in D-flat was written for Lev Oborin, who premiered it in Moscow on 12 July 1937, with the Moscow Philharmonic Orchestra under Lev Steinberg. The only piano available for the premiere was an upright piano, and the orchestra had just one rehearsal. The venue was an open-air stage in Sokolniki Park, and during the performance a strong wind blew Steinberg's glasses off, so that he could no longer see the score and had to conduct the remainder from memory. The piece is in three movements: the first movement, Allegro ma non troppo e maestoso, makes extensive use of the three-note theme of F, B, and A♭, illustrated above. Although the term "flexatone" is used, the second movement, Andante con anima, is one of the few classical pieces to make use of a musical saw, although this instrument is often omitted in performances and recordings of the concerto. The third movement, Allegro brillante, caps the piece in an exciting manner.

                                    2

                                    15:04

                                    • Add to cart
                                    • Add to project
                                    • Download
                                    • Stems
                                    • Cue sheet info
                                    • Similar
                                    • Share
                                    • Note
                                    • Like
                                    • Show actions
                                    • Details
                                  • Delete selected items from

                                    Are you sure?

                                  Cadenzabox

                                  hello@cadenzabox.com

                                  © 2026 Idea Junction Ltd. Powered by Cadenzabox

                                  This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent for cookies to be used.

                                  Accept Decline